Oh, Arizona, Not Again

I am not a resident of Arizona.  And I have to remind myself that I’m not a politician or legal scholar.  I live on the south side of Chicago.  I work in a church whose home has been on the northwest side of Chicago for eight years and that, this year, started a new church on the south side.  I am a pastor.  Happily.  

But I can’t help but be drawn to the behavior of the governor of Arizona.  You can learn about the newest law signed at their governor’s desk here or here or about last week’s uproar from the Governor’s perspective here.  There are other places.  Her state’s residents are saying interesting things on their blogs.  To be clear, this week’s law wasn’t about immigration.  It’s gotten better and better over in the desert state.

Governor Brewer signed a new law to stop state school’s from teaching ethnic studies.  Ethnic studies, of course, is the umbrella term for studies of color, especially brown.  The language of the law apparently gets at academic material which would overthrow the government or promote the hatred of someone of another racial background.

I think it’s bad to hate people from other backgrounds, and I think it’s sinister to pretend that a law cannot fundamentally encourage the hatred its intends to correct by explicitly promoting what amounts to the same. 

If a law like this came to Illinois, I’d have the following things to say to our legislators.  I think it’s meaningful for residents in general, parents, teachers and churches.

1) The reach of ethnic studies must be stretched.  Educating students on matters related to ethnicity and culture–in homes, schools, and churches–has to be for everyone.  Teachers and parents have to communicate to brown and black children that their culture is not simply for them, but that the formation and culture they receive affects others, including white children.  Apparently the AZ law doesn’t stop teachers from teaching studies as long as everybody is invited to take the class.  But I remember, at U of I, that the Black students hoped that non-Blacks took courses about Black studies.  I expect a similar hope across the nation since people of color like for white folks to know about our histories.

2) Parents are the best teachers, and faith communities aren’t bad either.  I’m a new father, but I’ve been a son for a long time.  I’ve learned my best lessons about respecting, loving, and being good to others while sitting on the lap and in the house that belonged to my mother.  My dad embodied generosity when I was child.  Parents are great teachers.  We need to tell our children the truth about who they are, where they come from, and what that means for how they lovingly engage with people from all corners in the neighborhood.  The church too.  The role of the church is to point to a reality that everyone’s experience is valuable to God and should be valuable to people.  If schools (state schools or otherwise) do not promote that truth, the community of faith, which is a diverse community since God’s family is multi-colored, must.

3) One group’s view has always been an introduction to disenfranchisement.  Howard Thurman, a theologian, talks about what it means to be disinherited and to fight a war of nerves.  He says, “If a man feels that he does not belong in the way in which it is perfectly normal for other people to belong, then he develops a deep sense of insecurity.”  For Thurman this is one of the things that is “worse than death.”  When legislators restrict educators from providing intellectually stimulating experiences from a variety of perspectives, the legislators are overpowering people from those perspectives.  After all, the kids are being taught.  The curriculum tells somebody’s side of the story.  When that happens, we’re steps away from not just re-writing history but erasing it.  I think the government has a responsibility to promote history as it’s been lived, even if the presentation of those stories tempts a student from believing the most popular history books.

4) Pushing for academic freedom equips and strengthens our communities.  It will diminish the value of education if our states follow Arizona’s dismal behavior.  Native, African, and Latino American people have something to say and not just to their specific communities.  Their messages and histories are vital to the broader United States of American public.  And I don’t intend to suggest that our white scholars and storytellers have little to say–only that those stories are either already heard, are more likely to be heard, or so pervasive inside our country’s books and classes that uplifting the former people groups does little to diminish the later.

5) Culture matters.  Race matters.  Ethnicity matters.  It matters to the Creator who painted, cooked or crafted our skins with an array of colors.  All those colors come with stories.  One shouldn’t be esteemed to the detriment of another.  Sure, politicians should be concerned that no one be taught in a state school how to dishonor the governmental system of that state.  Of course, we must promote in our learning centers civility and respect and dignity.  But none of that happens when we edit the truth from those who search for it.

I’d love to know what you think.  About any of this.


5 thoughts on “Oh, Arizona, Not Again

  1. Thank you, Michael, for helping me see the AZ current events from your perspective. I’m thankful for who you are, where you live, how you serve–and how all of that combines to enrich your viewpoint. You are a great communicator and teacher–I look forward to learning more from you.

    I have to admit to being very confused about AZ. The laws in the spotlight right now seem so misguided to me,-but I’ve not read them, and like you, I’m not a lawyer. At the same time, if I was one of AZ’s lawmakers and was living with the consequences of the current situation, I don’t know what I’d be driven to do if I was responsible for law and order, safety and security for all the citizens in my jurisdiction And–that’s just it–as lawmakers, they are responsible for the citizens first, visitors second. I would hope that my faith and belief system would give guidance in how to love the stranger while meeting all my responsibilities.

    I would love to hear faith based, love motivated solutions put forward rather than just criticism. It is easy to point out flaws, it is harder to point to solutions. I think you have done both in your post! Good job!!! We need to know and understand each others history, cultures, perspectives while also being taught respect for each other and how to properly engage and effect change where change is needed.

    • Linda, I would imagine that a lot of good folks in Arizona are confused by the tension between creating laws and living justly. I don’t envy Arizona’s legislature but I do hope they’re open to their residents’ concerns around these developments.

  2. Well I live here & work in the schools as an educator. I’ve made a decison to take my expertise as a deaf educator and my own childre
    n to another state where the land isn’t as stifling.

    As of July 1st, I will no longer call AZ home.

    It’s bad when you go into the staff lounge (the day after Obama won) and see his face scribbled on in all the newspapers. Childish

    • April, I can only imagine what it’s like teaching within the school system when this news came. Be encouraged as you take these next steps. It’s good to read your comment on this too. Really helpful to see your perspective. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s